Campaigns Democracy Economy & Finance General Election 2024 Green Party Holyrood Election 2026 Labour Left Politics Political Parties Political Philosophy RedClyde Scotland Scottish Council Elections 2027 Scottish Greens Scottish Independence Scottish Socialist Party SNP SNP Socalists Socialism Ungagged Writing

​A Party Losing Its Soul: Why Scottish Socialists Are Looking Beyond the SNP

By Guest Columnist “Redclyde.”

My SNP branch is changing. There is clear anger across the tables and zoom screens. After 2014, there was little to split us, though Salmond and the conspiracy theorists tried. The SNP had realised that like all real campaigns for change, the working class are key.

 

For nearly two decades, the Scottish National Party (SNP) has maintained its political dominance by occupying a carefully calibrated centre-left ground. It has presented itself as a social-democratic alternative to Westminster austerity while reassuring business interests of its fiscal prudence. However, following the May 2026 Holyrood elections, which saw the SNP retain power as a minority government amid significant vote losses in post-industrial seats and a surge for both the Scottish Greens and Reform UK, that balancing act has come under sustained fire. Across Scotland’s political left, from parliamentary allies to radical socialists and trade unions, a consensus has emerged. Under First Minister John Swinney, critics inside and outside of the party argue that the SNP has drifted toward a cautious, centre-right managerialism that betrays its progressive promises, undermines its climate credentials, and hollows out the radical case for Scottish independence.

 

​Nowhere is the rupture between the SNP and the Scottish left more visible than on environmental and energy policy. By reversing the party’s previous presumption against new North Sea oil and gas exploration and opposing a UK-wide ban on new licences, Swinney’s government triggered accusations of “North Sea oil hypocrisy” from its former coalition partners, the Scottish Greens. When the Greens forced a Holyrood vote in November 2026 to halt drilling at the massive Rosebank oil field, they framed themselves as “the last party standing up for our environment”, capitalising on an influx of disillusioned former SNP members. This environmental scepticism extends beyond fossil fuels to industrial infrastructure. Progressive commentators in outlets like The National and Green campaigners have criticised ministers for championing energy-hungry AI data centres without transparency regarding their ecological, water, and grid impacts on local communities. To its left-wing critics, the SNP’s willingness to subordinate ecological limits to short-term commercial investment signals a clear retreat from a just transition.

 

​This perceived retreat from bold policy is mirrored in the left’s economic critique, which characterises the Scottish Government not as a progressive shield against Westminster, but as a compliant manager of austerity. Following Swinney’s September 2026 Programme for Government, Scottish Socialist Party (SSP) co-spokesperson Colin Fox dismissed the agenda as “lacklustre” and accused the First Minister of “going through the motions”. Fox pointed out that Swinney had become the seventh successive First Minister to pledge the eradication of child poverty without enacting the structural wealth redistribution or aggressive use of devolved tax powers necessary to achieve it. Trade unions and local authorities have echoed this frustration, condemning Holyrood’s “top-down” local government reforms and chronic underfunding of municipal services. In the eyes of organised labour, passing Westminster budget cuts down to local councils while refusing to challenge underlying economic orthodoxy leaves working-class communities bearing the brunt of failing social care, strained public services, and stagnant living standards.

​Crucially, socialist and pro-independence commentators argue that this domestic caution directly corrodes the movement for Scottish independence. As historian Rory Scothorne observed in The Guardian following the 2026 election, the SNP suffered steep vote drops across Scotland’s post-industrial central belt, creating a political vacuum that allowed the hard-right Reform UK to make alarming inroads. Left-wing writers in The National have warned that the party’s rightward drift alienates the very working-class and younger voters needed to build a pro-independence majority. Rather than offering independence as a vehicle for transformative social change, radical left outlets like Socialist Worker argue that the SNP relies on a sterile, purely constitutional strategy revolving around draft referendum bills and Section 30 requests. In their view, this treats independence as electoral “blackmail” to keep left-wing voters from backing socialist alternatives. Furthermore, Swinney’s attempts to counter Reform UK by forging a cross-party “popular front” alongside unionist establishment parties like the Conservatives have been derided by the radical left as a strategic dead end. They argue it reinforces the SNP’s image as defenders of a failing status quo rather than leaders of grassroots, working-class resistance.

​Taken together, these critiques reveal a profound ideological crisis for the Scottish National Party -and my branch. For years, the promise of independence allowed the SNP to bridge the divide between progressive aspirations and cautious governance. Yet in the post-2026 landscape, left-wing critics contend that this formula has exhausted itself. By retreating on climate action, settling for incrementalism in the face of poverty, and aligning with establishment norms to defend its parliamentary position, the SNP risks losing both its progressive soul and the working-class coalition essential to achieving its founding constitutional goal. Some of us are at present, casting around for democratic socialist new homes.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.